I really enjoyed Boogie Nights. I disagreed with everyone else and thought that Magnolia was one big wank. I thought Punch Drunk Love was absolutely awesome.
It’s true, Adam Sandler does put on a fantastic performance in this film, and you must understand that this complement is coming from someone who absolutely loathes Adam Sandler movies.
Luis Guzman’s role was pretty much a big waste of time for all involved (there simply isn’t much for him to do), and it’s fantastic to see Philip Seymour Hoffman in a different role for a change. For once he wasn’t someone that inspired pity and/or revulsion.
I can imagine that this film did nowhere near as well as Boogie Nights or Magnolia, but believe me it’s better than those two put together.